This text is a part of The D.C. Temporary, TIMEs politics e-newsletter. Join right here to get tales like this despatched to your inbox.
Its unattainable to go greater than 10 minutes on cable information and even one scroll on social media proper now with out confronting some model of the identical argument: that the federal government shutdown provisionally slated to begin this weekend is the fault of Republicans and voters will bear in mind it. Republicans appeared resigned to being the heavies for an entire give up of the political excessive highway, and Democratsperhaps over-confidentlythink that is all gravy for them.
This all has echoes of a decade in the past, virtually to the day, when lawmakers in Washington stood able to shut down the federal authorities in hopes of torpedoing the Reasonably priced Care Act, A.Okay.A. Obamacare. And identical to again then, Virginias off-year elections are just some weeks away, and the shutdown could also be heavy on voters minds once they go to the polls.
The legend in Washington has been that the 2013 shutdown delivered Virginia Democrats a blowout. But the historical past shouldn’t be as clear-cut because the rhetoric would counsel. In actual fact, it’d give Republicans in close by Washington justified causes to barrel ahead on the haphazard path they’re already on.
Identical to now, Congress again then was break up between a Republican-led Home and a Democratic-led Senate the place Democrats lacked the 60 votes wanted to beat a filibuster. Heading towards shutdown, Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas, who usually appeared extra centered on organising his bid for president than governing, learn Inexperienced Eggs and Ham on the Senate flooring as a part of his 21-hour effort to delay any dealmaking. (For the historic document, it was not technically even a filibuster as a result of that days legislative enterprise was already over and Cruz was blocking no reside votes. Critical mainstream Republicans rolled their eyes in disbelief.)
The shutdown lasted for 16 days. At its peak, 850,000 staff stayed residence and one other million needed to report back to work whereas hoping theyd get again pay in some unspecified time in the future. Per one estimate, the U.S. economic system misplaced a whopping $24 billion. Cruz and Co.s long-shot hopes that closing nationwide parks and never accumulating owed taxes would drive Obama to tug a U-turn on the central piece of his legacy by no means materialized. Even the leaders on the time admit at this time that it was a bungle.
This time we aren’t prone to be so fortunate as to endure via only a partial shutdown. Not one of many 12 must-pass spending payments is completed, and that features the sometimes easy-peasy protection and overseas operations spending payments. The troublemakers are getting their flip within the highlight and people accustomed to energy are discovering they’ve lower than they imagined. Pollsters are quietly warning that Republicans standing in Gallup is strictly the place it was proper earlier than the 2013 shutdown, at 38% favorable. When the 2013 shutdown started, the GOPs favorability plummeted a full 10 factors to twenty-eight%, the bottom quantity on document for both get together to that time since Gallup began asking the query in 1992.
That is the place Virginia is available in, as its Nov. 7 election is looming giant within the minds of these in search of clues as to which get together is best positioned going into 2024.
Virginia Republicans head into Election Day with a three-seat majority within the Home of Delegates and Democrats take pleasure in a four-seat majority within the Senatemeaning small margins matter, not only for Virginians however for nationwide strategists in search of classes from a shutdown.
A decade in the past, then-Gov. Bob McDonnell was coming off an opportunity to turn into 2012 Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romneys working mate and was clear-eyed about each his political future and what the legacy value could be for a messy off-year election that traditionally punishes the get together that received the White Home the yr earlier than.
My Republican buddies have gotten to grasp theres no means on earth that the President and the US Senate are going to vote to defund Obamacare, McDonnell informed reporters in Richmond, Va., forward of the shutdown. Look, I’m no fan in any respect of Obamacare. … However it’s completely improper to close down the federal government.
Distinction that now, with Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin making an attempt to separate the distinction: blaming President Joe Biden for a scarcity of management and urging persistence as fellow Republicans type out their inner variations. Right here is one other Virginian contemplating the nationwide stage, and he is aware of the bottom of the get together wont simply tolerate full-throated dissent in opposition to these intent on forcing a shutdown, even when they dont have any particular calls for.
Exterior of D.C., Virginia trails solely California within the variety of federal jobs, and the states army bases make use of 130,000 active-duty personnel and one other virtually 26,000 reservists, placing it behind solely California and Texas within the variety of women and men in uniform. Add in all of D.C.s federal staff who commute from Virginia, and you may see why the shutdown could be felt there extra strongly than different states.
In widespread lore, Virginias 2013 election shifted over the shutdown. The Democratic nominee for Governor, Terry McAuliffe, was polling 5 factors forward of Republican Legal professional Normal Ken Cuccinelli, the GOPs nominee for the highest gig, on the ultimate days earlier than the shutdown. By the point the shutdown had ended, the identical pollsters at Roanoke Faculty had McAuliffe up 15 factors. Cuccinelli went all-in on holding the conservative line and misplaced by 2.5 factors.
Wait, 2.5 factors? Wasnt Virginia imagined to be a Democratic blow-out due to the shutdown? Apparently not. Even within the state legislature, Republicans held regular at 67 seats within the 100-seat Home of Delegates.
It was an early signal that anger over a largely pointless shutdown shouldn’t be destined to essentially final lengthy. Nationally, Home Republicans picked up 13 web seats within the 2014 midterms and Senate Republicans picked up 9, only one yr after the lights went again on and Cruz shelved Dr. Seuss.
All of which is to say: voters at this time could also be rightly blaming Republicans for the looming shutdown that appears as silly as it’s unavoidable. However reminiscences are brief in politics, a brand new outrage is all the time across the nook, and even quick penalties, just like the one in Virginia again in 2013, can ignore nationwide tendencies so long as theres a stronger competing story. Doubt it? Take a look at how a lot cash is being spent in Virginia on advertisements about abortion. Its that potent challenge, and never appropriations, that each events suppose can win them these state legislative races. Social gathering elders on each side of the aisle shall be watching intently for indicators that their pondering on that’s proper over the following monthand possibly the yr that follows.
Make sense of what issues in Washington. Join the D.C. Temporary e-newsletter.