Gem Hunters Discovered the Lithium America Wants. Maine Wont Let Them Dig It Up

This story was printed in partnership with The Maine Monitor, a nonprofit and nonpartisan information group. To get common protection from the Monitor, join a free Monitor e-newsletter right here.

The world’s richest identified lithium deposit lies deep within the woods of western Maine, in a yawning, glowing mouth of white and brown rocks that appears like a landslide carved into the aspect of Plumbago Mountain.

Mary Freeman and her husband Gary discovered the deposit 5 years in the past whereas trying to find tourmaline, a hanging, multi-colored gemstone discovered within the area.

The Freemans make their residing promoting lab provides by way of the Florida-based firm they based 40 years in the past, Consciousness Expertise. However their real love is digging for gem stones, which has introduced them for years to Mary’s dwelling state of Maine, the location of a few of the greatest tourmaline searching on the planet.

Extra from TIME

Since 2003, they’ve been shopping for up property parcels, learning core samples and outdated geological maps to find out the place to attempt digging subsequent, then spending lots of of 1000’s of {dollars} a yr on blasting and tools. The couple has dug greater than a mile of tunnels in pursuit of lovely stones, and plenty of of their finds—like blue elbaite and wealthy watermelon tourmaline—have wound up on show on the Maine Mineral & Gem Museum in close by Bethel.

Now, the Freemans wish to increase this pit, close to the city of Newry, Maine, to allow them to mine spodumene, crystals that comprise the lithium the U.S. wants for the clear power transition. The timing of their discovery, in what has been named Plumbago North, is exceptional; the Freemans have stumbled throughout one of many solely hard-rock sources of lithium within the U.S. at a time when the fabric is desperately wanted for the clear power transition. By 2040, the world will want no less than 1.1 million metric tons of lithium yearly, greater than ten instances what it at the moment produces, based on projections by the Worldwide Power Company. Ought to the Maine deposit be mined, it could possibly be price as a lot as $1.5 billion, an enormous windfall for the Freemans and a boon to the Biden Administration’s efforts to jumpstart extra home mining, processing, and recycling of vital minerals reminiscent of lithium, cobalt, and uncommon earth parts to scale back the U.S.’ dependence on China. This is likely one of the few lithium deposits within the U.S. at the moment present in onerous rock, which suggests it’s higher-quality and quicker to course of than lithium mined from brine.

“I think about myself an environmentalist,” says Mary, who on a current wet go to to the take a look at quarry, was carrying denims, a sweater, and mountain climbing boots, her white hair pulled right into a low ponytail. Many of the nation’s vital minerals are mined elsewhere and processed in China, she provides. “I believe [the U.S.] ought to attempt to be a little bit bit extra self-sufficient.”

Learn extra: Lithium Is Key to the Electrical Car Transition. It’s Additionally in Brief Provide

However like nearly in all places within the U.S. the place new mines have been proposed, there’s sturdy opposition right here. Maine has a few of the strictest mining and water high quality requirements within the nation, and prohibits digging for metals in open pits bigger than three acres. There haven’t been any energetic steel mines within the state for many years, and no firm has utilized for a allow since a very strict legislation handed in 2017. As extra firms start prospecting in Maine and looking for sizable nickel, copper, and silver deposits, cities are starting to cross their very own bans on industrial mining.

“It is a story that has been performed out in Maine for generations,” says Invoice Pluecker, a member of the state’s Home of Representatives, whose hometown of Warren—a 45-minute drive from the capital metropolis of Augusta—not too long ago voted overwhelmingly in favor of a short lived ban on industrial steel mining after a Canadian firm got here searching for minerals close to a beloved native pond. “We construct industries based mostly on the wants of populations not residing right here after which the underside drops out, leaving us struggling once more to choose up the items.”

Mainers usually invoke the Callahan Mine within the coastal city of Brooksville as a warning. Tailings from the mine, which operated for a number of years within the late Nineteen Sixties, had been disposed of in a pile subsequent to a salt marsh and creek. The previous mine is now a Superfund web site, and a 2013 research by researchers at Dartmouth School discovered widespread proof of poisonous metals in close by sediment, water and fish. Cleanup prices, borne by taxpayers, are estimated between $23 million and $45 million.

“Our gold rush mentality relating to oil has fueled the local weather disaster,” says State Rep. Margaret O’Neil, who introduced a invoice final session that might have halted lithium mining for 5 years whereas the state labored out guidelines (the laws finally failed). “As we facilitate our transition away from fossil fuels, we should look at the dangers of lithium mining and think about whether or not the advantages of mining right here in Maine justify the harms.”

The Freemans’ level out that they plan to dig for the spodumene, then ship it out of state for processing, so there could be no chemical ponds or tailings piles. They liken the excavation of the minerals to quarrying for granite or limestone, which enjoys a protracted, wealthy historical past in Maine.

Advocates for mining within the U.S. argue that, for the reason that nation outsources most of its mining to locations with much less strict environmental and labor laws, these harms are at the moment being born by overseas residents, whereas placing U.S. producers within the precarious place of relying on faraway sources for the minerals they want. Although there are greater than 12,000 energetic mines within the U.S., the majority of them are for stone, coal, sand, and gravel.

There is just one operational lithium mine within the U.S., in Nevada, and one operational uncommon earth aspect mine, in Mountain Move, Calif., that means that the U.S. depends on different nations for the supplies important for clear power applied sciences like batteries, wind generators, and photo voltaic panels. Even after they’re mined, these supplies at the moment need to be shipped to China for processing for the reason that U.S. doesn’t have any processing services.

“If we’re speaking about vital metals and supplies, we’re to this point behind that it’s loopy,” says Corby Anderson, a professor on the Colorado Faculty of Mines. “It’s the dichotomy of the present administration—they’ve incentives for electrical automobiles and all these items, however they want supplies like graphite, manganese, nickel, cobalt, lithium, and copper. The one one we mine and refine on this nation is copper.”

The COVID-19 pandemic laid naked the issues of faraway provide chains; as U.S. customers shopped on-line of their houses, the products they purchased, principally from Asia, skilled prolonged delays at clogged ports. What’s extra, diplomatic tensions with China motivated the U.S. authorities to hunt different potential sources for mining, materials processing, and recycling.

That’s why, within the pandemic’s aftermath, the Biden Administration launched an initiative to safe a Made in America provide chain for vital minerals. It included billions in funding for firms making an attempt to mine and course of vital minerals domestically.

The rocks in Plumbago North would appear to assist present a home provide chain for vital minerals; they’re considered among the many largest specimens of spodumene ever discovered, with crystals of such prime quality that along with batteries, they could possibly be used to make scientific glassware or laptop screens, the place the lithium steel would assist decrease the melting temperature.

The Freemans are simply two of the lots of of individuals prospecting for vital supplies throughout the nation because the U.S. tries to strengthen the home provide chain. In line with an evaluation by Patrick Donnelly, the Nice Basin Director for the Middle for Organic Range, a nonprofit environmental group, greater than 100 firms have staked claims for lithium deposits within the American West. Corporations even have utilized for permits to mine cobalt in Idaho, nickel and copper in Minnesota, and lithium in North Carolina.

Geologists say there’s additionally seemingly much more lithium in spodumene deposits throughout New England. Communities that haven’t had working mines in years might quickly discover themselves a key supply for lithium and different minerals wanted for automotive batteries, photo voltaic panels, and most of the objects individuals will want extra of to transition themselves off polluting fossil fuels.

There are good causes for U.S. communities to have wholesome skepticism about mining initiatives; there isn’t a scarcity of examples of an organization coming right into a group, mining till doing so turns into too costly, then leaving a polluted web site for another person to wash up. There are greater than 50,000 deserted mines within the western United States alone, 80% of which nonetheless should be remediated. Passage of landmark environmental legal guidelines just like the Clear Air Act of 1970 and the Clear Water Act of 1972 hasn’t made mining protected sufficient, environmentalists say.

“All mines pollute in a method or one other, and mines are actually unhealthy at predicting how a lot they’re going to pollute,” says Jan Morrill, who research mining on the environmental group Earthworks, which not too long ago discovered that 76% of mining firms within the U.S. polluted groundwater after saying they wouldn’t.

One of the problematic components of mines is the tailings, or waste, Morrill says: Corporations extract the minerals they want, then are left with an enormous pile of rock, liquid, and chemical substances that they retailer in ponds or behind dams that typically show unstable. These tailings have prompted landslides, extreme mud, and water air pollution; greater than 300 mine tailing dams have failed worldwide over the past century, based on Christopher Sergeant, a analysis scientist on the College of Montana.

It isn’t unusual for tailings to leak into water, in actual fact, there’s a allow that mine house owners can get in case they discover their projections had been fallacious and they should discharge into U.S. waters.

Even “trendy mines” that adhere to the newest U.S. requirements—that are among the many strictest on the planet—nonetheless pollute, Earthworks has discovered. Although there are, theoretically, non-polluting methods to retailer mine tailings, doing so is way more costly and mine operators have largely not paid to take action, Morrill says. That’s as a result of, says Aimee Boulanger, govt director of the Initiative for Accountable Mining Assurance, “legal guidelines and markets haven’t absolutely incentivized firms to do this.”

Certainly, the Biden initiative to extend home mining contains, for instance, a $700 million mortgage for Ioneer, an organization planning a lithium mine on Rhyolite Ridge in Nevada, the place environmental teams say the mine, as proposed, would trigger the extinction of an endangered species referred to as Tiehm’s buckwheat. The Administration can be spending $115 million to assist Talon Nickel construct a battery minerals processing facility in North Dakota, however the potential mine they might supply from, in Minnesota, is opposed by Indigenous teams and environmentalists who concern it might contaminate wells within the space.

Nonetheless, the U.S. has a extra rigorous regulatory setting than many different nations, she says, and there are home mines that even some environmentalists help, just like the Stillwater Mine in Montana. Group organizations there signed a Good Neighbor Settlement in 2000 with the Sibanye-Stillwater Mining Firm permitting the agency to extract platinum and palladium—whereas additionally establishing clear and enforceable water requirements, restrictions to reduce native visitors, and third-party auditors to make sure the mine adheres to the requirements it set out. The mine is now one of many prime employers and private-sector revenue turbines in Montana.

However advocates needed to pressure the Settlement; three grassroots organizations sued to cease the development of the mine, and after a yr of negotiations, the mining firm and grassroots teams agreed to the contract as an alternative of going to courtroom. With help from elected officers looking for methods to mine extra vital minerals within the U.S., firms might not really feel the necessity to make related guarantees to the area people.

Learn extra: What Would Occur if South America Shaped an OPEC for Lithium

Environmental issues aren’t the one downside with mining, Morrill says. The historical past of mining within the U.S. is linked to colonialism; Christopher Columbus was searching for gold when he stumbled throughout North America, and as Europeans expanded into the continent, they took land from Indigenous individuals to mine for gold, silver, and different metals.

At this time, mining within the U.S. usually encroaches on Indigenous land. Below mining legal guidelines within the U.S. that date to 1872, anybody can stake a declare on federal public lands and apply for permits to begin mining in the event that they discover “worthwhile” mineral deposits there. Most lithium, cobalt, and nickel mines are inside 35 miles of a Native American reservation, Morrill says, largely as a result of within the aftermath of the 1849 gold rush, the U.S. navy eliminated tribes to reservations not removed from mineral deposits within the West. In a single notably controversial undertaking, the mining firm Rio Tinto desires to construct a copper mine on Oak Flat, Ariz., a desert space adjoining to an Apache reservation that Indigenous teams have used for hundreds of years to conduct cultural ceremonies.

But fears concerning the results of local weather change are escalating the strain on native communities to get out of the best way of mines, says Thea Riofrancos, an affiliate professor of political science at Windfall School who research mining and the inexperienced power transition. She and different students have questioned whether or not projections that the world will face lithium shortages by 2025 are correct; recycling extra batteries and transitioning away from personal automobiles to extra public transportation, for instance, might scale back our long-term want for lithium-ion power storage.

“We should always take into consideration what’s driving this demand, why does this rush really feel so intensive, why is there not a model the place we’re going to try to do that transition with the least quantity of mining attainable?” Riofrancos says.

Most environmentalists agree that the 1872 mining legislation must be up to date and there are a number of payments in Congress that might achieve this. The Clear Power Minerals Reform Act of 2023, for instance, launched by Sen. Martin Heinrich (D-NM) in Might, would require extra tribal session and alter how mining is accredited on federal lands.

Discovering a technique to mine within the U.S. might assist handle an ethical quandary, that we eat these supplies however ask different nations to bear the brunt of their extraction, says Boulanger, with IRMA.

“There’s an argument to be made that if we’re going to make use of these supplies, and we reside in probably the most consumptive nation on the planet, we shouldn’t be making different nations be the checking account of our pure sources,” she says.

If lawmakers and regulators can’t agree on the right way to mine on U.S. soil, it might depart the U.S. vulnerable to primarily outsourcing its mining issues to less-regulated nations. For instance, final October, the Division of Power used the Bipartisan Infrastructure Legislation to offer a $141.7 million grant to Piedmont Lithium, which is constructing a plant in Tennessee to increase U.S. provide of lithium hydroxide, utilized in long-range batteries for electrical automobiles. In March, Blue Orca Capital, a hedge fund, mentioned it was “shorting,” or betting in opposition to the inventory of Piedmont Lithium, alleging that the spodumene the agency plans to refine into lithium at its Tennessee facility was assured by bribes to the son of a high-level politician in Ghana—“due to corruption,” these uncooked supplies are prone to by no means come to fruition, the hedge fund says. Piedmont denies the allegations and says in an announcement offered to TIME that the Minerals Revenue Funding Fund of Ghana advised the corporate that it has legitimate licenses and permits for all its present actions.

Many of the proposed vital supplies mines within the U.S. usually are not close to a giant inhabitants heart—or financial exercise, and a few communities are in favor of a mine for the roles it might create. However the proposed places might as an alternative result in conditions the place sparsely populated communities don’t find out about a deliberate mine till it’s too late to cease it. “It might really feel actually quick—hastily an infinite undertaking is being proposed subsequent door to you, it took years for the corporate to prospect however you didn’t hear about it ‘til now,” says Riofrancos.

The Freemans’ mine will not be considered one of these initiatives. Although it’s 5 miles from the closest city, Maine goes by way of an intensive evaluate course of to determine whether or not to let the couple preserve digging. Earlier in 2023, there have been seven payments within the legislature relating to the potential of mining lithium in Maine. Lawmakers finally settled on laws that will open the door to extracting the Freemans’ lithium by permitting bigger open pit steel mines, as long as builders can show they gained’t pollute groundwater and the native setting. However the brand new legislation would require altering the state’s mining laws, which can imply it could possibly be years earlier than the couple is ready to begin digging in earnest.

The Freemans say their mine wouldn’t pollute the encircling land and water, because the chemical composition of the crystals and the rocks round them is such that they might not dissolve into harmful acid when uncovered to air and water. Geologists that TIME/Maine Monitor spoke with agree with that evaluation. Additional, the crystals, says Mary, could be shipped out of state in giant chunks for processing, so there could be no chemical ponds or tailings.

Many geologists agree that the Freemans’ proposal wouldn’t be as disruptive as different proposed mines throughout the nation. Different metals (like nickel, silver, and zinc) sometimes happen in bands of rock deep under the floor that comprise iron sulfides, which create sulfuric acid when uncovered to air and water, polluting waterways for many years, a phenomenon often called acid mine drainage. Some spodumene crystals at Plumbago North, in contrast, have been naturally uncovered to air and water for lots of of hundreds of thousands of years and never damaged down.

On a go to to the take a look at quarry this spring, Gary Freeman identified one giant piece of spodumene mendacity on the backside of a close-by brook, the water over it speeding quick and clear, not the rusty orange of an acid-contaminated stream. (The waterway is understood, fittingly, as Spodumene Brook.) “The water is so good Poland Spring desires to bottle it and promote it,” says Mary.

Nonetheless, Morrill, of Earthworks, says there’s simply not sufficient analysis concerning the results of onerous rock spodumene mining to say for positive that the mine wouldn’t hurt the setting. Since so many individuals in Maine rely upon recreation and tourism for his or her livelihoods, she says, it makes probably the most sense to maintain protecting laws in place.

Maine’s Division of Environmental Safety has rejected the Freemans’ request to contemplate the land a quarry, and is as an alternative classifying spodumene as a metallic mineral. Because the legislation stands, the Freemans must apply for permits below Maine’s 2017 Metallic Mineral Mining Act, a expensive course of (the appliance processing payment alone is $500,000) that might take years.

In the meantime, the area people is split. In spite of everything, in Maine it’s not troublesome to seek out individuals nonetheless residing with the long-term harm of older mines. However, many Mainers are pragmatic and perceive the state has lengthy, darkish winters, and can want battery storage for any renewable power it generates on sunny or windy days. The choice is to proceed counting on fossil fuels, which might exacerbate local weather change.

Learn extra: Tesla Co-Founder JB Straubel Has a Repair for the Battery Drawback

Myles Felch, curator on the Maine Mineral and Gem Museum, is considered one of these sensible Mainers. He was raised in Union, the place a groundswell of opposition has fashioned to withstand a proposal by Canada-based Exiro Minerals to search for nickel close to a beloved native pond. Felch isn’t thrilled with the prospect, but additionally is aware of we will’t proceed to be so indifferent from the minerals we use in our each day life.

“I like the place the place I grew up and I wouldn’t need something to ever occur to it,” says Felch. However “you want mineral sources. Most individuals had been in all probability texting ‘cease the mine’ with a nickel cobalt battery of their telephones.”

Contact us at [email protected].